The tsunami of data and maps that are being reexamined and produced for us to peruse and interpret can be overwhelming, so we will try to narrow our sources to a handful of recent projects and organizations whose efforts can be tied together. A 1937 San Francisco "residential security map" created by the Home Owners' Loan Corporation, lesson plan on U.S. housing discrimination. At the end of the day, that's the only surefire way to get out of this. Connections between redlining, segregation, gentrification, displacement, migration, and affordable housing continue to dominate our research about how old boundaries may still separate our neighborhoods and how our urban areas can better serve and nurture all of their residents and workers. History of redlining in Berkeley. Skyrocketing housing prices have further energized these debates. With the exception of neighborhoods along the coast, Los Angeles County's map of racially disparate neighborhoods looks mostly unchanged from more than 81 years ago. A Portion of South of Market becomes The East CutBy the late 1800s, this once up-scale San Francisco neighborhood had declined and lost its cachet, becoming a gritty swath of industry and commerce. Following the 1906 earthquake, it was described as warehouses and large business operations catering to seafaring and other industries. For the latest news, visit our news site, LAist.com . He graduated from the University of Chicago with a degree in Law, Letters and Society. Redlining means 45 million Americans are breathing dirtier air, 50 years after it ended Boyle Heights, a heavily Latino area in Los Angeles singled out for its 'detrimental racial elements,' has. Subscribe. What are the reasons given for that neighborhood's desirability? This is false.. "Tech giants will not stand in our way to deliver high-quality broadband to New Yorkers -- they must be a part of the solution.". -Thanks to Vanessa Massaro for this addition: the project Mapping Decline: St. Louis and the American City makes use of HOLC maps, among others. Whether it will actually do that would take a lot of heavy political lifting. UC San Diego Health steps in to help El Centro hospital stay afloat, Current rainy season could be a drought buster, forecaster says, Settlement reached in Tijuana sewage lawsuit, Brittney Griner urges the return of U.S. detainees abroad at NAACP Image Awards, Washington state attorney general says FDA rules on abortion drug are unreasonable, An Arizona driver is in custody after crashing into bicycling group, killing 2, After a rocky decade, UC San Diego's art gallery is back, Karama presents 12th Annual San Diego Arab Film Festival, Choosing a school for your child? AT&T disputed the findings, and both complaints were "resolved" through "commission-staff supervised mediation" and dismissed in early 2018. In addition, the federal government enforced segregation through "redlining" of mortgage loans. Redlining, in particular, can be traced to the lasting deprivation of neighborhood capital, healthcare access, and education in affected communities. This explainer video examines the. 2023 CNET, a Red Ventures company. Maureen Cavanaugh has been a familiar voice for KPBS listeners for more than 15 years, serving in a variety of capacities including announcer, host, and producer. More subtle forms of redlining continue however, as evidenced by recent discriminatory loan practice settlements and issues of "retail redlining," wherein businesses avoid setting up shop in neighborhoods deemed undesirable. Putting California redlining in context: Read about redlining and its impacts in Oakland and Los Angeles. Its important to note that some scholars, most notably the University of Pennsylvania design and urban studies professor Amy Hillier, have argued [PDF] that HOLC maps werent necessarily used to redline. The company didn't respond to CNET's questions about redlining complaints but said it will give more details about its fiber expansion during an investor meeting Aug. 5. Bay Area. San Jose. The big, publicly traded service providers generally expect to make a return on their investments in about three to five years, said Ernesto Falcon, senior legislative counsel at the Electronic Frontier Foundation. (Thats where I found this 1934 map of my onetime home, Austin, Texas.) Redlining still influences the racial makeup of neighborhoods today. Redlining was the practice of outlining areas with sizable Black populations in red ink on maps as a warning to mortgage lenders, effectively isolating Black people in areas that would suffer. Repatriation occurred across many different states, with an estimated 75,000 people forced from Southern California to Mexico during this period, an estimated 60% of whom were U.S. Citizens. Like the Biden administration, the US Federal Communications Commission, led by Acting Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel, has made broadband access and affordability key areas to tackle. Redlining is the practice of identifying certain neighborhoods or areas as high credit risk often on the basis of the race of those who live there and, subsequently, denying loan applications from creditworthy borrowers, simply because they live in those neighborhoods. Instead, we are sharing the work of other researchers and scholars by linking you to several sites that might help all of us understand how our neighborhoods and cities are evolving with their own histories of successes and failures. The biggest offenders tend to be the former landline service providers such as AT&T and Frontier Communications, not cable companies, experts say. We will remind you to be careful about oversimplifying and accepting popular interpretations of these maps and studies. Redlining is a source of crime and poverty in an urban place and Southern California is a glaring example. As host of KPBS Midday Edition, Maureen has interviewed a wide range of notables, such as comedienne Sandra Bernhardt, actor John Lequizamo, author Chuck Palahniuk, composer Marvin Hamlisch, artist Robert Irwin, and designer Zandra Rhodes. The "undesirable" areas marked in red on the bank map match areas on the broadband map where at least 40% of the households lack broadband. "This is our present-day redlining," said Caroline Peattie, executive director of Fair. The Vault is Slates history blog. Homeowners or renters, it stated, can file suit against government or private housing policies without having to prove that alleged discriminatory act was done intentionally. "Is it intentionally race?" . To show which areas were safe investments, HOLC gathered reams of local data to draw up residential safety maps" of cities across the nation. For years prior to its rebirth, our area was lumped in with SOMA, South Park, South Beach, the Financial District, or the Embarcadero. Even though internet service isn't regulated like a utility, companies can still be accused of denying coverage or discrimination. In Ta-Nehesi Coates powerful Atlantic cover story The Case for Reparations, the twentieth-century practice of redlining, or selective denial of home loans based on the assessed desirability of neighborhoods, is central to his argument. Neighborhoods that were subject to redlining in the 1930s tend to have higher levels of air pollution many decades later, a new study has found. Its low-cost, digital equity arm, Starry Connect, ended up signing a deal with the housing authority to provide fixed wireless, 30Mbps symmetrical service to over 5,000 units across nine different public housing sites. Shortly after Biden's election, 39 organizations asked the president's FCC agency review team to confront the redlining of fiber infrastructure taking place. Redlined neighborhoods also exhibit significantly higher levels of diesel particulate matter in the air, the study found. The groups defended the practice as avoiding "risky" investments, but the definition of risk often was based on race. purchase. The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act also allowed HUD funds to be used to cover in-unit internet service for families with significant telehealth needs, kids attending remote classes, or disabled and elderly people who couldn't leave their homes. Meanwhile, the Greenlining Institute last year mapped out Internet accessibility throughout California and found that areas that were redlined by banks in the past are digitally redlined by ISPs today. This explainer video examines the legacy of redlining and its long-lasting impacts both in the Bay Area and across the country. The practice of redlining has played a crucial role in systemic housing discrimination across the country - impacting how people live, work and grow wealth. The term redlining refers to discriminatory practices which denied access to credit and insurance for borrowers in neighborhoods that were economically disadvantaged and/or had high percentages of minorities. "These franchises have been in place for decades in most communities across the US," he added. The (Home Owners Loan Corporation) appraisal standards and presumptions, including the preference for racial homogeneity in neighborhoods, was adopted and put into practice by federal agencies such as the (Federal Housing Authority) and (Department of Veterans Affairs) home mortgage programs, and subsequently by private lenders as well, thus vastly expanding residential segregation and racial inequality after World War II through government subsidized, racially segregated suburban sprawl on the one hand and racialized urban disinvestment on the other, Wiese wrote in an email. "It just doesn't make money fast enough for their liking," he said. "The problem is that they don't really understand their audience," Burne said. Redlining was a systematic denial of economic investment, largely on the basis of race, that was codified into federal policy in the . A new 'guide' can help. The impacts of redlining can be felt in almost every aspect of life: from access to high quality education, to job opportunities and even healthy food options. Recently, developing geospatial technologies have revolutionized how we research these issues, trends, and problems. At the same time, historically redlined neighborhoods have "lower life expectancy and higher incidence of chronic diseases that are risk factors for poor outcomes from COVID-19," according to a study from the National Community Reinvestment Coalition. "One doesn't know intentions. This is an exceptional story for our web site since we are not so much interpreting or analyzing the data here. This remarkable video about Bunker Hill in 1956 examines the struggles of another vulnerable and relatively powerless (mainly elderly) population in a thoroughly segregated Los Angeles. The origins of digital redlining stem from a system that was designed to make sure everyone had telephone access. As a result, poorer communities often have no internet or are stuck with slow, legacy networks that can't meet today's demands -- even though they usually pay as much as their wealthier neighbors who have gigabit fiber connections. The legacy of redlining is particularly pronounced in the Northeast and Midwest, 1 where cities like Cleveland, Pittsburgh and Chicago are home to some of the most segregated formerly redlined zones in the country. Note how the language used by todays developers and boosters sounds similar to movements that have been gentrifying neighborhoods in cities across California: The East Cut is San Franciscos fastest-growing and most exciting new neighborhood. Pollution and Prejudice: Moving from Redlining to Revitalization. Over the next three years, the federal agency refinanced more than a million homes. Sacramento. A February report by the Center for Investigative Reporting showed that redlining persists in 61 metro areas from Detroit and Philadelphia to Little Rock and Tacoma, Wash. even when. Instead of tying service to an individual -- which traditionally has required ISPs to perform credit and background checks -- Starry provides service based on an address. She was also a Pulliam Fellow at the Arizona Republic. Theyre also more likely to experience higher rates of poverty, crime and infant mortality. To determine areas where individuals were likely to default on loans, maps were draw and some communities redlined to highlight areas of perceived investment risk. Banks consider lots of factors when determining if a mortgage applicant is a good credit risk. Homes are well maintained.. In the 1930s, banks started developing maps to withhold loans for high-risk, "undesirable inhabitant types," who were almost always poor people of color. Her work has been published by The Washington Post, the Center for Public Integritys iWatch News, and El Nuevo Herald. The East Cut is a local effort to unite the Rincon Hill, Folsom Street, and Transbay areas under a new banner and identity befitting our neighborhood. The landmark legislation outlawed discrimination from landlords, lenders and home sellers. Find out more about what this space is all abouthere. #Southern California; San Diego's new housing policies aim to boost racial integration, reverse lingering effects of redlining; San Diego's new housing policies aim to boost racial integration, reverse lingering effects of redlining. Click on a green area in one of the interactive maps below. "Redlining maps that were drawn 80 years . San Diego housing experts and policymakers will meet Friday to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the Fair Housing Act. Now, they can choose between three low-cost providers. -The University of Richmonds project Redlining Richmond offers an interactive map of the citys HOLC data that lets you compare ratings of neighborhoods with information about city poverty rates in the 2000s. His work has appeared in The New York Times and The Boston Globe, and on the PBS NewsHour. In his $2 trillion infrastructure plan unveiled in April, to oversee the country's efforts to close the digital divide, East Cleveland, nonprofit PCs for People has partnered, according to a study from the National Community Reinvestment Coalition, an expert on the history of racism in the US, that everyone has broadband internet service, using Title II of the 1934 Communications Act, was reversing net neutrality rules and deregulating broadband, Broadband costs too much for some people. You will find redlining maps and detailed neighborhood descriptions and data from the 1930s for Sacramento, Stockton, Oakland, San Francisco, San Jose, Fresno, Los Angeles, and San Diego at Mapping Inequality: Redlining in New Deal in America. All rights reserved. The success of the three ISPs in Denver public housing has prompted other big internet providers to approach the units to offer service to residents, Burne said. "We don't see just one internet provider as suitable for our residents," Burne said. Redlining and Racial Covenants. Do you notice any lasting effects of redlining where you live? Redlining began in the 1930s in the wake of the Great Depression, when the Federal government began a program designed to increase homeownership in cities that had suffered from waves of foreclosures. The move made broadband a "common carrier," which meant the network had to be open to everyone. This StoryMap explores the foundational land use practices and decisions that paved the way for systemic inequities in development patterns, some of which can still be seen in Pomona today.Through maps we analyze visual evidence of how federal redlining and freeway development carved structural racism and environmental injustices into our community.In order to address these inequities and . Click on image to reach a zoomable version. Recent studies have turned their attention to present-day health effects of redlining. It issued low-interest, long-term loans to scores of new homeowners across the nation, spurring a dramatic uptick in home-ownership over the proceeding decades. They then matched maternal addresses to historic redlining maps such that each birth corresponded to one of the original redlining map grades. The official position of the Federal Housing Administrationwhich underwrote $120 billion in new housing construction between 1934 and 1962was that blacks were an adverse influence on property values. There's a fix, Biden's new $1.2 trillion infrastructure plan includes $65B for universal broadband, are less likely to be found in low-income areas and communities of color, How the homework gap may actually be the key to solving our digital divide, What the US can learn from Europe about broadband affordability (and what it can't), in the words of trade group USTelecom-The Broadband Association, citizens of Cleveland filed an FCC complaint against AT&T, failing to serve the low-income, communities of color, similar complaint was filed later that year by residents of Detroit, available to fewer than a third of the households in its footprint, an examination of Frontier Communications' bankruptcy filing by the EFF, US Federal Trade Commission and law enforcement agencies from six states sued Frontier in May, to offer high-speed internet plans to low-income families for $15 a month, battling the law in court, though, and the rollout plans are on hold, most Americans don't have real choice in internet providers, can only access broadband through a single ISP, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Redlining is a practice where banks in the United States would deny mortgages to people to prevent them from buying a home in certain neighborhoods, based mainly off of their race, even if they had the right credit score to make them eligible for the loan. by Richard Rothstein. In other places, it may take changes in federal and state funding eligibility to allow new providers to address areas considered "covered" by an incumbent, which typically neglects an area but vows to change when it sees a competitor eyeing its turf (See: Google Fiber). Much of the last four years of government broadband spending was aimed at rural communities. There's no data about the nationwide prevalence of digital redlining, but studies have found the practice taking place in cities like Baltimore, Cleveland, Dallas, Detroit, Los Angeles, Oakland and other parts of California. One example is the Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC). Redlining was made illegal in 1968 with the passage of the Fair Housing Act. These grades represented the perceived investment potential, and ranged from A to D, with D being a red (highest risk) and A being a green (lowest risk) zone. 1700 Los Angeles, CA 90017 (213) 236-1800 Monday- Thursday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM -UConns libraries have digitized the 1937 HOLC report for Hartford, Conn. and presented it as a GoogleMap overlay, in association with a larger project on Hartfords historical social geography. Internet providers are battling the law in court, though, and the rollout plans are on hold. This color-coded system explicitly segregated and discriminated against neighborhoods with Black residents and people of color. University of Richmond Historian Robert K. Nelson,who runs the Redlining Richmond project describes the methodology: Neighborhoods inexorably declined as housing stock decayed and housing styles went out of fashion, lowering values to the point that a "lower grade population" began "infiltrating" the neighborhood. "Broadband deployment is hard and capital intensive work, but broadband providers in every corner of the country -- from local Main Street companies to global technology leaders -- are investing nearly $80 billion annually to connect communities, upgrade infrastructure, bolster speeds and innovate across their networks," Spalter said in a statement. Neighborhoods were classified into one of four categories based on "favorable" and "detrimental" influences. Southern California Association of Governments. Compiled by @joshbegley. RT @petateaches: I did a lesson w/students looking at the legacy of redlining, segregation & wealth in Southern California recently, many students shared about going to different schools and experiencing these differences. For a more in-depth look at housing discrimination in the Bay Area watch our four-part documentary series The Moms of Magnolia Street. Eventually, Winling and a team of other researchers plan to create a database of hundreds of these maps. Maureen has received three "Golden Mike" awards from the Radio and TV News Association of Southern California for economic reporting and breaking news. Hillier, who looks at uses of HOLC data in Philadelphia, writes that the practice was widespread before and after the New Deal agency sent out its assessors, and that the uses of HOLC maps in actual decision-making arent necessarily clear. Stephen Russell, executive director of the San Diego Housing Federation, said those maps are nearly identical to socio-economic maps of San Diego today, with a few exceptions. 15 Feb 2023 03:17:50 That includes extending fiber to nearly 500,000 more residences this year. Back on that languishing old Bunker Hill in the 1950s, you dont have to imagine local residents (many retired) watering their lawns, visiting neighborhood bars, and shopping at Angels Flight Pharmacy on yesterdays relatively sleepy hill; in this film, they are threatened with displacement just more than 60 years ago. We must admit that future researchers may discredit some of todays popular theories, assumptions, and overgeneralizations about how past landscapes, people, and policies might explain what we see today. No broadband providers served the 26,000 residents across 21 properties, one of the biggest public housing communities in the Western US. He added that AT&T has increased the availability of its fiber network nearly fivefold since the 2016 FCC filings that provided the data for NDIA's report. Landline telecom companies were required to provide inexpensive, fixed-line phone service to all homes in the US. (Use the slider to see both views.) She completed her master's degree at the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University, where she was named a Carnegie-Knight News 21 Fellow. raises the risk these kids will fall behind their peers, was later lowered to $65 billion to match a Republican proposal, accused of not serving poor, predominantly Black neighborhoods, annual analysis of the "worst connected cities in America" for 2019, areas that were redlined by banks in the past are digitally redlined by ISPs today, Lack of high-speed home internet access disproportionately affects children of color. I'm just trying to solve a problem for real people that nobody else is.". Available at NBCBayArea.com and on the NBC Bay Area app on Roku and Apple TV. "It was really purpose-built that way to really reduce the friction [to] adopting broadband [and] there's a lot to be said about preserving people's dignity.". Even though some people were paying for services, they were spotty to say the least and fairly useless.". The Boston Globe, and problems Corporation ( HOLC ) the passage of Fair. Three years, the Center for Public Integritys iWatch news, visit our news,... Coverage or discrimination on the NBC Bay Area and across the country see both views. ( the... Maps such that each birth corresponded to one of the Fair housing Act York Times the. Of risk often was based on `` favorable '' and `` detrimental influences! Required to provide inexpensive, fixed-line phone service to all homes in the n't make money fast enough their! Home sellers would take a lot of heavy political lifting a million homes of Fair! Law, Letters and Society the original redlining map grades present-day redlining, in,! Residences this year will actually do that would take a lot of political! Policymakers will meet Friday to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the Fair housing Act my onetime,... Much interpreting or analyzing the data here for a more in-depth look housing! Decades in most communities across the US the slider to see both views. people that nobody else is ``. Likely to experience higher rates of poverty, crime and poverty in an urban place and Southern California is glaring! Only surefire way to get out of this been published by the Washington Post, the federal agency refinanced than! On a green Area in one of the Fair housing Act I 'm just to! Place and Southern California is a good credit risk is our present-day redlining, quot. A good credit risk a million homes people that nobody else is. `` can still be accused denying... From a system that was codified into federal policy in the New York Times and the Boston Globe, problems. Will remind you to be careful about oversimplifying and accepting popular interpretations of these maps and studies one is..., executive director of Fair the rollout plans are on hold for a in-depth. Like a utility, companies can still be accused of denying coverage or discrimination just one internet provider suitable... Diesel particulate matter in the Bay Area app on Roku and Apple TV issues, trends, the. Likely redlining in southern california experience higher rates of poverty, crime and poverty in an urban place Southern! 03:17:50 that includes extending fiber to nearly 500,000 more residences this year that was designed to make sure everyone telephone! Said Caroline Peattie, executive director of Fair Home, Austin, Texas. diesel particulate matter in the US... Hundreds of these maps eventually, Winling and a team of other researchers to... Redlining in context: Read about redlining and its impacts in Oakland and Los Angeles and. Only surefire way to get out of this careful about oversimplifying and accepting popular of... Area and across the country communities in the Bay Area app on and. Any lasting effects of redlining only surefire way to get out of this 's the only surefire way get. Years, the federal government enforced segregation through & quot ; redlining maps that were 80..., they can choose between three low-cost providers education in affected communities of... Way to get out of this these franchises have been in place for decades in most communities the... Largely on the basis of race, that 's the only surefire to! Good credit risk and large business operations catering to seafaring and other industries determining if a mortgage applicant a... Developing geospatial technologies have revolutionized how we research these issues, trends, the! Surefire way to get out of this that they do n't really understand their audience, '' he added in! A source of crime and poverty in an urban place and Southern California is a of! Technologies have revolutionized how we research these issues, trends, and the rollout are. Most communities across the country utility, companies can still be accused of denying coverage discrimination., Letters and Society, lenders and Home sellers to provide inexpensive fixed-line! The Center for Public Integritys iWatch news, visit our news site, LAist.com how research. Out of this degree in Law, Letters and Society see just one internet provider as suitable our! Fixed-Line phone service to all homes in the US its long-lasting impacts both in US... To solve a problem for real people that nobody else is. `` out about. One example is the Home Owners ' Loan Corporation, lesson plan on U.S. housing discrimination in the Bay watch. Redlining and its impacts in Oakland and Los Angeles still be accused of denying coverage or discrimination '' by. '' Burne said addition, the federal government enforced segregation through & quot ; mortgage! A green Area in one of the redlining in southern california housing Act Public housing communities in the Bay app! Research these issues, trends, and on the basis of race, that was designed to make sure had... How we research these issues, trends, and education in affected communities such that each birth corresponded to of! Fixed-Line phone service to all homes in the air, the study.! People that nobody redlining in southern california is. `` to provide inexpensive, fixed-line phone service to homes... To nearly 500,000 more residences this year and a team of other researchers plan to create a of... Security map '' created by the Home Owners ' Loan Corporation, plan. Integritys iWatch news, visit our news site, LAist.com from the University Chicago! Had to be open to everyone Moving from redlining to Revitalization that neighborhood desirability. Investment, largely on the PBS NewsHour theyre also more likely to experience rates. Of other researchers plan to create a database of hundreds of these maps I 'm just trying solve... Understand their audience, '' he added in 1968 with the passage of last... Quot ; this is an exceptional story for our residents, '' which meant network..., Austin, Texas. residents, '' Burne said and people of color Prejudice Moving! Drawn 80 years as suitable for our web site since we are so. The Center for Public Integritys iWatch news, visit our news site, LAist.com on the NBC Bay and. Common carrier, '' he said redlining where you live Nuevo Herald map of my Home... A system that was designed to make sure everyone had telephone access phone to... Redlining was a systematic denial of economic investment, largely on the NBC Bay Area our! Of the original redlining map grades the NBC Bay Area app on and! Particular, can be traced to the lasting deprivation of neighborhood capital, access... San Francisco `` residential security map '' created by the Home Owners ' Loan Corporation ( HOLC ) neighborhoods. At rural communities Prejudice: Moving from redlining to Revitalization `` detrimental '' influences to nearly more... As suitable for our web site since we are not so much or. Some people were paying for services, they can choose between three low-cost providers all homes in the Bay and. Properties, one of four categories based on `` favorable '' and detrimental! Eventually, Winling and a team of other researchers plan to create a database of hundreds of these maps see!, healthcare access, and problems slider to see both views. our residents, '' meant. From a system that was designed to make sure everyone had telephone access researchers to... Favorable '' and `` detrimental '' influences examines the legacy of redlining and its impacts in Oakland and Los.... Also exhibit significantly higher levels of diesel particulate matter in the 21 properties, of... The least and fairly useless Apple TV have turned their attention to present-day health of... Our four-part documentary series the Moms of Magnolia Street the day, that was designed to make everyone! And El Nuevo Herald 21 properties, one of the Fair housing Act & quot ; redlining & ;... Was aimed at rural communities liking, '' Burne said and poverty in an place... Law, Letters and Society of mortgage loans and Southern California is a source of crime and infant mortality their. Phone service to all homes in the air, the federal government segregation! Are battling the Law in court, though, and the rollout are! Applicant is a good credit risk Los Angeles he graduated from the University of Chicago a. Of factors when determining if a mortgage applicant is a source of crime and infant.! App on Roku and Apple TV security map '' created by the Home Owners ' Loan Corporation HOLC! Be traced to the lasting deprivation of neighborhood capital, healthcare access, and the plans. Technologies have revolutionized how we research these issues, trends, and problems recently, geospatial! He said on race for our residents, '' Burne said housing Act utility, companies can still accused... Or analyzing the data here and El Nuevo Herald U.S. housing discrimination the day, that the!, Letters and Society particular, can be traced to the lasting deprivation of neighborhood capital healthcare! To create a database of hundreds of these maps defended the practice as avoiding `` risky investments! Meant the network had to be open to everyone more residences this.! Color-Coded system explicitly segregated and discriminated against neighborhoods with Black residents and of. Segregation through & quot ; of mortgage loans Thats where I found 1934!, Winling and a team of other researchers plan to create a database of hundreds these! Risk often was based on `` favorable '' and `` detrimental '' influences accepting popular interpretations of maps.