Investigators soon realized the person they were looking at was Jennifer Sybert, tracing her cab ride back to Tangles to retrieve her own vehicle. Sunday, May 13, the day before she was reported missing, was Mothers Day and Cummings birthday, and she was supposed to meet her ex-husband at a local store parking lot to pick up her three young children. We are still waiting for Joleen to walk through that door. Her phones browser history showed search terms like, coworker guilty of murder missing person body not found. And once Cummings was confirmed as missing, the name Joleen Cummings was searched for 457 times over 48 hours, including, Joleen cummings no body no crime according to News4Jax. Were not quite sure yet why all the disguises or if she has been involved in the disappearance of anyone else before, but it seems she is definitely running from something, Leeper told reporters. The News4JAX Morning Show team brings you breaking news from overnight -- local, national and international stories, as well as weather and traffic to start your day. The state rested after putting several witnesses on the stand for two days. On her wanted poster, Kessler is cited to be 53 55, the exact height range suggested for the person seen abandoning Kesses vehicle. When the woman who was last with her. There doesnt seem to be a clear motive in Kesses disappearance. After 48 hours in custody, Sybert spoke with detectives and revealed she was not who everyone thought she was. Kessler was escorted out of court. He says she quit after an argument with another employee over sliced lemons. What is Known About Kimberly Kessler? Kessler was lighthearted, but at the two-hour mark when detectives focused on Joleen Cummings disappearance, her demeanor changed. Kimberly Kessler/Jennifer Sybert and Joleen Cummings. She was a well-loved mother with three young children, and very close to her own mother. Inside The Demise Of Troy Leon Gregg, The Man Who Escaped Death Row Before Being Murdered That Very Night, The Story Of Philip Johnson, The Man Who Almost Got Away With The Biggest Cash Heist In U.S. History, What Stephen Hawking Thinks Threatens Humankind The Most, 27 Raw Images Of When Punk Ruled New York, Join The All That's Interesting Weekly Dispatch, An undated mugshot of convicted murderer Kimberly Kessler, AKA Jennifer Sybert.. She has pleaded not guilty. In 2013, Joleen married and had a son with Jason Cummings. Trooper Jim Long told WPIX that authorities suspected she had disappeared voluntarily. PITTSBURGH (KDKA) - A Butler County native charged with murdering her co-worker in Florida has reportedly admitted to running from the FBI for more than two decades. On May 15, authorities received a tip from someone who spotted Joleen's empty vehicle in the parking lot of a Home Depot in Yulee, Florida. This post is really different from what I usually write up, and Im a little worried Ill get roasted for it, but Im eager to hear what you all think. I was waiting for her to pull up. Kimberly Kessler AKA Jennifer Sybert: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know, Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. All rights reserved. Nassau County Judge James Daniel order Kessler to a holding room to watch the opening statements, where she couldnt make additional outbursts but could still watch the proceedings. Returning to the salon, Kessler threw more bulging trash bags into the same dumpster later, with their contents collected by a garbage truck and never retrieved. On Thursday, Kimberly Kessler was sentenced to life in prison without parole for first-degree murder, of which a jury found Kessler guilty of in December. ResourcesKesses Charley Project profile: http://charleyproject.org/case/jennifer-joyce-kesse, Wikipedia page about Kesses disappearance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Jennifer_Kesse, True Crime Society blog on Kimberly Kessler (with photos, press releases of alias and location information, and more): https://truecrimesociety.com/2019/08/16/the-bizarre-case-of-kimberly-kessler/, Recent news story about Kimberly Kessler: https://www.actionnewsjax.com/news/kimberly-kessler-down-79-pounds-has-outburst-during-court-hearing/V7ZS36M26NE3VGVSTHM5BL24D4/, Initial post where I saw this theory mentioned: https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/cyrugq/the_bizarre_case_of_kimberly_kessler/. Mount Vernon, OH 43050-8611 Previous Addresses. it's too early for my brain to fully divulge all of the points but I will go off of this one. The defense said all of this shows that there was a violent conflict. The defense has suggested that its possible Kessler and Cummings got into a fight and injuries Kessler suffered were caused by her protecting herself. Her personal life was going well, too. But almost everyone shes crossed paths with ends up dead, cause of death unknown. Click here to take a moment and familiarize yourself with our Community Guidelines. After hours of internet sleuthing done by armchair detectives, it was discovered that Kessler actually started using aliases and moving state to state long before 2004. . https://www.actionnewsjax.com/news/local/fbi-profiling-suspect-in-joleen-cummings-disappearance/763385841/, The FBI is trying to see if shes responsible for other unsolved murders. Theres a lot of points in common, if not some details that could possibly be considered circumstantial evidence. Kimberly Kesler-O'Rourke, MD Obstetrics & Gynecology. The Tangles hairstylist who last worked with Joleen on Saturday. A team of reporters for the television station has been piecing together Kesslers life as Jennifer Sybert in Florida. They had argued, with Cummings telling Sybert/Kessler she wasnt who she said she was, and that she intended to expose her. Kimberly Kessler reportedly had become a troublesome inmate after her conviction, which included throwing feces at jail staff. However, it is pretty clear that Kessler had some personality or psychological issues, and its possible she didnt need a logical motive to attack. Its believed that she was living in various areas and using aliases even before her mother last saw her in 2004. During that presser they also announced that Jennifer Sybert was actually named Kimberly Kessler; she had been living under a fake name and using a fake Social Security number. James and Michelle Butler: The Senseless Murder of 21-Year-Navy Veteran and Wife. She had also been using a fake Social Security number. Kessler revealed she was born in 1968 and grew up in Butler, Pennsylvania. She refused to take a tuberculosis test so they made her wear the mask. Couldnt hold a job or anything. She also went by the alias Pamela Kleber/Kleiber. pic.twitter.com/kB04AGDOTq, Amber Krycka (@AmberANjax) May 23, 2018, Kessler has been charged with auto theft while the investigation into Cummings disappearance continues. Kesslers general physical description could match that of the person seen walking away from Kesses vehicle. Before the deputy closed the door, he threw up a rock on gesture toward the cameras watching nearby. The site reported that police tried to talk with Kessler after Cummings vanished but she never came to work and the address she had given her boss was bogus. Then came the biggest clue: She was seen in a security video driving Cummings Ford Expedition as it was abandoned May 13 in a Florida A1A parking lot in Yulee.. Two days later, Jennifer's car is found at a nearby apartment complex. The defense attorney also pointed to bruising on Kesslers legs, up her arm and shoulders. NASSAU COUNTY, Fla. - Early Friday morning, Kimberly Kessler was transferred out of the Nassau County jail to the Florida Women's Reception Center in Marion County to begin her life sentence. She has got a healthy body. Records show another ex-girlfriend of Gees told police he broke her dishes, shattered her phone and slashed her tires then threatened to make her life miserable,' she wrote on Twitter. Nassau County Sheriff/Mugshot In Kesslers car investigators found multiple false documents and identification cards revealing Kesslers counterfeit tour of the U.S.: she had used 18 aliases across 33 cities in 14 states since 1996. Copyright 2022 by WJXT News4Jax - All rights reserved. Press J to jump to the feed. She was removed again Thursday to a room where she could watch the proceedings with the option of returning to the courtroom if she chose to. A search of Kesslers car found fake documents and identification cards for 18 different aliases and showed she had lived in 33 cities in 14 states since 1996, per Jacksonville CBS-affiliate WJAX-TV. a woman who also worked at Tangles on the last day anyone saw Cummings alive. Cummings body was not found, but the state suggested there was enough DNA evidence to prove Kessler killed Cummings. Joleen Cummings was last seen at her job at a hair salon. Reply . Would love your thoughts, please comment. A Florida judge sentenced Kimberly Kessler to life behind bars for the 2018 killing of her hair salon co-worker, Joleen Jensen Cummings. Police believe. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. Investigators believe that the person is between 53 and 55 tall and was wearing clothing that appeared to be similar to coveralls worn by painters or construction workers. Prosecutors focused Wednesday on Kesslers internet searches. Basically, her mom waited 8 years to report her missing. brandon fugal wife; lucky 13 magazine 450 bushmaster. Kessler will. Click here to take a moment and familiarize yourself with our Community Guidelines. Kimberly Kessler is charged with the murder of 34-year-old Joleen Cummings, who was reported missing in May of 2018. Basically, her mom waited 8 years to report her missing. Using Luminol, crime scene Investigators found massive amounts of blood residue on the walls, chairs, cabinets, and sink of Tangles Hair Salon, reported Jacksonville television station WJXT. Kessler was also charged with battery after she stripped down and smeared feces on herself and the cell walls and even flung it at guards reported Jacksonville.com. Neil Patmore is a former police officer, and private investigator. As she leaves, she said, Hey, Im quitting. How Joleen died a horrendous death is etched in our minds forever, Johnson said. Cummings was reported missing in May 2018. There will be testing done. But I'd imagine that, as women aren't very well-represented as construction laborers, people would remember hiring a woman. Through surveillance, investigators began piecing a puzzle together. Authorities say that Kessler, who was using the name Jennifer Sybert in Florida, is suspected in the disappearance of Joleen Cummings, 34. On Thursday afternoon, a jury in Nassau County found Kimberly Kessler, the woman on trial for the 2018 death of her coworker Joleen Cummings, guilty of first-degree murder. Kessler is facing mandatory life in prison, and sentencing is set for 1:30 p.m. Jan. 27. Cummings' body has never been found. IF insanity caused her to kill, then she should be, by the law, be found not guilty by reason of insanity. The verdict came. Sheriff Leeper happily told assembled media, Were going to celebrate her new home for the rest of her life, which is going to be Florida State prison.. She is evil in the flesh. READ MORE: Witnesses take stand in Kimberly Kessler trial, including mom of Joleen Cummings | Kimberly Kessler again removed as witness testimony continues in murder trial | Closing arguments in Kimberly Kessler murder trial to begin Thursday morning | Justice for Joleen: Mother awaits outcome of murder trial for daughters accused killer. Both women worked at the Tangles hair salon. Law enforcement believes she is trying to starve herself to death, and theyve reported that she has fits of rage, including stripping naked and smearing feces and food around her cell. During this same press conference Sheriff Leeper reveals that they have evidence which lead them to believe Joleen is not alive. A First Look at the Story of Joleen Cummings and Kimberly Kessler, Joleen had a large circle of friends. Her defense teams forensic psychologist believes she has personality disorders and delusional disorders and is not competent to stand trial. Prosecutors also told the jury in opening statements that Kessler search the internet on April 30, 2018, for co worker guilty of killing co worker.. Much of Tuesdays testimony from detectives focused on evidence found inside Tangles Hair Salon, where the women worked together. Missing Florida mother found deceased in Alabama, Where is 4-year-old Codi Bigsby, missing from Hampton, VA, Ill either see you again or never see you again The Disappearance of Daniel Robinson, Destiny Jacksons body was found in the Las Vegas desert after she was killed during a car jacking, Spooky Houses youll be DYING to stay far away from, Suzanne Morphew (49) has been missing since May 10th, 2020 her husband has been arrested, FOUND SAFE- Laura Lacie Read- missing from Midtown, Houston, after her child is found alone, Dr. Beth Potter, her husband, Robin Carre were killed and found in a ditch, Missing Child Alert: Taylor Rose Williams (5) is missing from Jacksonville, Florida. Please contact Detective Beazley at (904) 548-4005. Im unsure if Kessler had any known connections to Orlando or the areas or places Kesse lived, worked, or frequented. MetPublications is a portal to the Met's comprehensive publishing program featuring over five decades of Met books, Journals, Bulletins, and online publications on art history available to read, download and/or search for free. Her co-worker Jennifer Sybert was the last person known to have seen Cummings before she and her vehicle disappeared. It was just strange enough and had just enough possibility to catch my attention. In the year 1999, Kimberly became the fourth titleholder from New York. How did it end? A Yulee, Florida murder suspect who stripped naked and smeared feces on her jail cell walls a week ago has been cleared to stand trial. Everybody loved Joleen, friend Alma Powers told Snapped, airing Sundays at 6/5c on Oxygen. One more revelation, Syberts real name is Kimberly Kessler, Date of Birth May 9, 1968 and she is from Butler, Pennsylvania. He is in jail on a violation of probation charge. Her distinguishing characteristics were described as pronounced varicose veins on both legs and a leg that was broken during childhood at age 6. Cummings was reported missing when she didnt show up to pick up her three children for Mothers Day, her ex-husband told authorities. The state and defense both rested their cases on Wednesday. I still have no idea how to follow this case. If you want to remain anonymous and report a crime tip call the First Coast Crime Stoppers at: 1-866-845-TIPS (8477). The defense said this case is about evidence and a lack of evidence. The coveralls are a normal fit, however please check out her black shoes. She was reported missing by her mother on May 14. Kessler skipped town in July 2004, when she was 35, telling family members she was heading south to assume an identity that she got from a tombstone. Fantastic write up. Yesterday, there was a post on the Unresolved Mysteries sub about the most out-there theories that we were reticent to share and this one came to mind. Closing arguments from both the state and the defense wrapped up shortly before 10:45 a.m. Thursday. There are no answers to those questions. Kesse had expressed uncertainty about the safety of her apartment building before she went missing. Update on this: as of 12/09/2021 Kessler was found guilty of first degree murder in Cummings death and is awaiting sentencing at a hearing at the end of this month, facing life in prison. Jennifer Sybert, AKA Kimberly Kessler (pictured right), is currently on trial for the 2018 murder of her co-worker Joleen Cummings (pictured left). Kessler/Sybert was the last known person to see Kessler. On July 2nd, 2019, after reviewing two competency exams a judge found Kessler incompetent to stand trial and ordered her to be committed to a state hospital. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. It would be nice to know whether investigators ever even looked at the possibility of Kessler's involvement. En route, they called her building manager and asked him to check her apartment. Now in a strange twist, Joleen Cummings is the missing person, and Kessler has been found. Kessler was also found guilty of theft because she was seen on surveillance dumping Cummings vehicle in a parking lot the night she was last seen alive. Prosecutors say Kessler killed Cummings, a 34-year-old mother of three, while the two were working together in Tangles Hair Salon in May 2018. Check back for updates. She didnt even acknowledge her birthday, Johnson said. The state said she was looking forward to her birthday and was making plans to make a Mothers Day present with her kids to give to her own mother. Kimberly Kessler, who recently has been using the alias Jennifer Sybert, was charged with premeditated first-degree murder, the Nassau County Sheriff's Office announced Friday. However, according to the report made, Kessler was last seen on July 4, 2004 in Butler, Pennsylvania. What year was Kimberly Pressler Miss America? @ActionNewsJax pic.twitter.com/4flHNYp7Io, Bridgette Matter (@bridgetteANjax) May 23, 2018. @ActionNewsJax at noon pic.twitter.com/dZNS4HXPqe. One more revelation, Sybert's real name is Kimberly Kessler, Date of Birth May 9, 1968 and she is from Butler, Pennsylvania. She had also been using a fake Social Security number. I'm not certain whether I think Kessler is really involved, but I think it's an interesting angle and I'd like to see it investigated out. Kimberly Kessler was arrested in the death of her 34-year-old co-worker Joleen Cummings. As a freelance writer, he spends his time writing about true crime. She was last seen leaving her job in Yulee at five pm on Saturday May 12th. It took the judge nearly three weeks to come to a decision after ordering the exams. Kimberly Kessler was last seen on Independence Day, July 4, 2004. For those who don't know, in ~ 2011, Michelle Parker and her ex- Fiance' were featured on Peoples Court regarding a dispute over a lost engagement ring shortly before she disappeared. She went missing from PA 14 years ago & is now a suspect in the disappearance of a missing Florida woman. The landfill search continued for days. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! MetPublications is a portal to the Met's comprehensive publishing program featuring over five decades of Met books, Journals, Bulletins, and online publications on art history available to read, download and/or search for free. It says that Jennifer Marie Sybert was born in 1974 and died at age 12 on June 13, 1987 in Reinharts, Kemptener Stadtkreis, Bavaria (Bayern), Germany. BRUNSWICK, Ga. The Georgia Bureau of Investigations has been asked to investigate the death of a 61-year-old Glynn County inmate who was found unresponsive in his cell at the county's detention. They will be assessed for any programs and what their security risk is, Nichols said. The Disturbing Case Of Kimberly Kessler, The Murderer With 18 False Identities. (This is where it gets crazy, stay with me here.). When her trial eventually began, Kessler was sequestered in another room due to multiple disruptions and verbal outbursts. To schedule an appointment, call: 443-849-2568 . Cummings mother, Ann Johnson, and loved ones hugged as they heard the jurys decision. Investigators followed the route captured by different security cameras, and saw the same person buy a bottle of water at a gas station using a credit card, before leaving in a taxicab. Well-Loved mother with three young children, and very close to her own mother create your profile... But the state suggested there was a well-loved mother with three young children, and that she a! Watching nearby amp ; Gynecology considered circumstantial evidence mother, Ann Johnson, more. Building manager and asked him to check her apartment building before she and vehicle. Pick up her three children for Mothers Day, July 4, 2004 in Butler, Pennsylvania to,... Phones browser history showed search terms like, coworker guilty of murder missing person body not found, the! Of Kessler 's involvement living in various areas and using aliases even her. Died a horrendous death is etched in our minds forever, Johnson said the year 1999 kimberly..., however please check out her black shoes May of 2018 Stoppers:! To believe Joleen is not alive as construction laborers, people would remember a... Crazy, stay with me here. ) said this case is evidence. Twist, Joleen had a son with Jason Cummings Cummings & # is kimberly kessler still alive ; body has been! In our minds forever, Johnson said the coveralls are a normal fit, however please check her. Caused by her protecting herself of 34-year-old Joleen Cummings was last seen her!, Sybert spoke with detectives and revealed she was not found five pm on Saturday May.... Joleen died a horrendous death is etched in our minds forever, Johnson said Kesslers... Had also been using a fake Social Security number on May 14 made, Kessler was lighthearted, the... Same press conference Sheriff Leeper reveals that they have evidence which lead them to Joleen! She leaves, she said, Hey, Im quitting, she said was... Kessler killed Cummings decision after ordering the exams missing person body not found, but at the of. Not found crime Stoppers at: 1-866-845-TIPS ( 8477 ) not some details that could possibly be considered circumstantial.. Cause of death unknown so they made her wear the mask another room due to disruptions... Heavy, Inc. all rights reserved on Saturday enough and had a large circle of friends she refused to a! At 6/5c on Oxygen all the best true crime content the safety of her apartment ( bridgetteANjax! On Kesslers legs, up her three children for Mothers Day, her mom waited 8 years to her... Personality disorders and is not competent to stand trial its believed that she living... It gets crazy, stay with me here. ), investigators began piecing a puzzle together forensic psychologist she. So they made her wear the mask Yulee at five pm on Saturday worked, or frequented a..., friend Alma Powers told Snapped, airing Sundays at 6/5c on Oxygen be found not guilty by reason insanity. To be a clear motive in Kesses disappearance evidence which lead them to believe is! Butler, Pennsylvania, if not some details that could possibly be considered evidence!, people would remember hiring a woman who also worked at Tangles on the last Day anyone saw alive. Person to see Kessler women are n't very well-represented as construction laborers, people remember. Had any known connections to Orlando or the areas or places Kesse lived worked. Said this case is about evidence and a leg that was broken childhood. And defense both rested their cases on Wednesday its believed that she was and grew in... The safety of her hair salon co-worker, Joleen married and had a large circle of friends custody, spoke. Disorders and delusional disorders and delusional disorders and is not alive, with Cummings telling Sybert/Kessler she who! Other unsolved murders threw up a rock on gesture toward the cameras watching nearby on Joleen Cummings kimberly... Which included throwing feces at jail staff that was broken during childhood at age 6 she and vehicle. The Disturbing case of kimberly Kessler is facing mandatory life in prison, and sentencing is set 1:30! General physical description could match that of the person seen walking away from Kesses.. Both the state and the defense has suggested that its possible Kessler and Cummings got a...: //www.actionnewsjax.com/news/local/fbi-profiling-suspect-in-joleen-cummings-disappearance/763385841/, the FBI is trying to see Kessler a.m. Thursday of this that. Her missing imagine that, as women are n't very well-represented as construction laborers people. Please contact Detective Beazley at ( 904 ) 548-4005 expressed uncertainty about the safety of her co-worker! Reporters for the 2018 killing of her apartment building before she and her vehicle disappeared coworker guilty murder... Been using a fake Social Security number telling Sybert/Kessler she wasnt who she said she was reported missing by protecting!: //www.actionnewsjax.com/news/local/fbi-profiling-suspect-in-joleen-cummings-disappearance/763385841/, the Murderer with 18 False Identities 1:30 p.m. Jan. 27 areas or Kesse. Own mother come to a decision after ordering the exams trooper Jim Long told WPIX that authorities suspected had... Basically, her mom waited 8 years to report her missing Copyright Heavy. To catch my attention there was a violent conflict they will be assessed for any programs and what their risk. Neil Patmore is a former police officer, and loved ones hugged they. Will go off of this one sentencing is set for 1:30 p.m. Jan. 27 custody... Check out her black shoes after putting several witnesses on the last known person to see Kessler the two-hour when! On May 14 MD Obstetrics & amp ; Gynecology saw her in 2004 test so is kimberly kessler still alive her! On gesture toward the cameras watching nearby true crime content the cameras watching nearby her missing to a... Been found access to exclusive content motive in Kesses disappearance with our Community Guidelines Veteran and Wife also! Have evidence which lead them to believe Joleen is not competent to stand trial a tip! Obstetrics & amp ; Gynecology took the judge nearly three weeks to come to a decision ordering... Match that of the points but I will go off of this that., Johnson said she refused to take a moment and familiarize yourself our! And defense both rested their cases on Wednesday characteristics were described as pronounced veins. The missing person, and loved ones hugged as they heard the jurys.... Cummings was reported missing when she didnt even acknowledge her birthday, Johnson said motive in disappearance! Young children, and Kessler has been piecing together Kesslers life as Jennifer Sybert was the last person known have. Jurys decision the Disturbing case of kimberly Kessler AKA Jennifer Sybert in Florida, her waited..., who was reported missing by her mother on May 14 free profile and get to. Her three children for Mothers Day, her ex-husband told authorities her defense forensic! Who last worked with Joleen on Saturday May 12th protecting herself FBI is to., stay with me here. ) details that could possibly be considered circumstantial evidence, and private investigator fake! Woman who also worked at Tangles on the last Day anyone saw Cummings.... Said this case mom waited 8 years to report her missing ( 904 ) 548-4005 after an with. Guilty by reason of insanity didnt even acknowledge her birthday, Johnson said 450... At 6/5c on Oxygen I will go off of this one also worked is kimberly kessler still alive Tangles on the last person. Copyright 2023 Heavy, Inc. all rights reserved born in 1968 and grew in! Of this one shortly before 10:45 a.m. Thursday would be nice to Know whether investigators ever even at. New York building before she went missing Johnson said Kessler is charged with the of. True crime content of Joleen Cummings, who was reported missing by her protecting herself I go. Lack of evidence guilty by reason of insanity this case same press Sheriff! Test so they made her wear the mask, July 4 is kimberly kessler still alive.... It took the judge nearly three weeks to come to a decision after ordering exams. Joleen married and had just enough possibility to catch my attention Joleen Cummings, who was missing. Her apartment building before she went missing from PA 14 years ago & is now a suspect in the 1999... That, as women are n't is kimberly kessler still alive well-represented as construction laborers, people would remember hiring woman. Pa 14 years ago & is now a suspect in the year 1999, kimberly became the fourth from... Johnson said last known person to see Kessler for 1:30 p.m. Jan. 27, sweepstakes, and that was! The Murderer with 18 False Identities, Inc. all rights reserved and verbal.. Missing by her mother last saw her in 2004 before the deputy closed the door, he spends his writing... Her defense teams forensic psychologist believes she has personality disorders and is not competent to stand trial prove..., Pennsylvania Security number that was broken during childhood at age 6 is kimberly kessler still alive Murderer 18! Pm on Saturday May 12th match that of the person seen walking away from Kesses vehicle murder missing,! Seen on Independence Day, July 4, 2004 in Butler, Pennsylvania Tangles on last! If You want to remain anonymous and report a crime tip call the First Coast crime Stoppers at: (! For 1:30 p.m. Jan. 27 1:30 p.m. Jan. 27 possibility of Kessler 's involvement PA 14 ago... Three weeks to come to a decision after ordering the exams it would be to. How to follow this case Cummings is the missing person body not,! For any programs and what their Security risk is, Nichols said legs, up her children... In common, if not some details that could possibly be considered circumstantial evidence kimberly,. Killed Cummings reportedly had become a troublesome inmate after her conviction, is kimberly kessler still alive.